State-federal relations and American antienvironmentalism

Youngstown Sheet and Tube Firm’s Campbell Works, Youngstown, Ohio (c. 1960)

Ohio Valley Historical past lately printed Allen Dieterich-Ward's "'We’ve Bought Jobs. Let’s Combat for Them': Coal, Clear Air, and the Politics of Antienvironmentalism". From the introduction (notes omitted):

Narrating the historical past of the environmental opposition has grown in significance over the previous 4 a long time because the fast growth of environmental legal guidelines gave technique to a conservative antienvironmental motion decided to roll again insurance policies seen as difficult older authorized imperatives and in battle with financial targets. Because the 1980s, first journalists after which historians have targeted on the backwards and forwards of environmental policymaking. The fundamental narrative is of an environmental backlash, which started within the mid-1970s in western states—the Sage Brush Revolt that fashioned one of many conservative pillars in Reagan’s coalition. By the 1990s, protests over tightening federal land rules coalesced ideologically into the clever use motion, which presupposed to be a contemporary replace of Progressive Period practices (conservationist Gifford Pinchot coined the time period “clever use” in 1910). As environmental politics grew to become more and more partisan, resurgent Republicans in Congress, resembling Idaho’s Helen Chenoweth, Tom Delay of Texas, and Alaskan Don Younger seized on the ideas of clever use and made rolling again environmental rules key to their “Contract with America.”

The Sage Brush Revolt narrative offers a compelling shorthand for journalists and historians alike and is probably correct in describing one aspect of the rise of the environmental opposition. Nevertheless, the broader narrative of a grassroots backlash prompted by the relative liberalism of the 1970s has lately confronted criticism by students who level out the methods this framework can masks the purposeful top-down methods of highly effective elites searching for coverage wedges to divide the Democratic political coalition. Additional, the regional focus of the Sage Brush Revolt poses the identical issues for the story of antienvironmentalism because the overemphasis on the American West that has usually characterised scholarship on the environmental motion. Whereas western considerations about federal land possession generally dovetailed with fears amongst jap politicians, industrialists, and blue-collar staff concerning the results of environmental regulation on jobs, the latter proved not less than as decisive in shaping the political panorama as conservationists throughout the Republican Celebration have been first sidelined after which largely eradicated on the nationwide degree. The saga of the noticed owl and old-growth forests within the Pacific Northwest, in any case, can not totally function a stand-in for battles over algae blooms in Lake Erie or acid rain within the Ohio Valley and New England. In industrial cities like Gary, Indiana, and Cleveland, Ohio, opponents of environmentalism seized on plant closures as proof constructive of their considerations about privileging “clear air and pure water” over “jobs and continued financial progress.” 

Learn extra »

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *